Group seeks to fight effects of Orange’s revaluation

Thursday, October 19, 2006

 

By Patrick Justin Fahey - Staff Writer

 

A group formed to fight the effects of Orange’s property revaluation met recently to discuss ways to find tax relief.

 

Patricia Weston Rivera, the group’s vocal leader, suggested during the Oct. 12 meeting that city officials decrease the number of tax-exempt properties in the city and questioned what kind of tax breaks new developments may be receiving.

 

One problem that Rivera has is that there has been a large shift in the tax burden from commercial properties to residential properties. Rivera pointed to the amount of profits some businesses achieve. As an example, Rivera cited the White Castle at Scotland Road and Central Avenue. Rivera said it does a great business, however, rather than a tax increase, White Castle’s taxes went from $47,590 to $17,969.

 

While Rivera said she understands that a business is assessed only on its land and building and not the amount of profit they make, she said she believes that the land the White Castle is on could be put to better use.

 

“Let’s get rid of the White Castle,” she said, “build condos or something on that spot to increase ratables.”

 

Pavel Manrique also spoke to the crowd of about 75 people. He stressed that individuals should make sure there were no mistakes on their new assessment by asking for a meeting with Appraisal Systems, the company hired by the city to do the revaluation, to review the reassessment.

 

“Make sure all of the information in the report for your house is correct,” Manrique said. “Make sure that if you have a two- bedroom house, only two bedrooms show up in the report, not three or four. If you have two bathrooms, make sure no more than two show up in the report.”

 

This is exactly what Edson Elysee has already done. According to Elysee, Appraisal Systems originally had his home listed as a six-bedroom with a finished attic.

“I only have three bedrooms, and my attic isn’t finished,” he said. Elysee indicated that when he brought the mistakes to the attention of Appraisal Systems, the company corrected the discrepancy.

 

Manrique also stressed that property owners reviewing their revaluations should pay attention to decks and fireplaces, which increase the assessment value of a house.

 

“Make sure it is not in the report if you don’t have one,” said Manrique.

 

Manrique told the audience to bring at least five “comps,” or comparable sales, to a meeting, showing that similar houses are selling •for less then a resident’s reassessed value. He said the “comps” must be within a one-mile radius of the residence.

 

“One thing I ask of all of you is to get involved,” Manrique said in concluding his presentation. “The city council will only listen to us and do something about it if we keep voicing our needs, so please, get involved.”

 

Manrique later said he believed that reviews of individual assessments and individual tax appeals were the best bet for relief in the short run.

 

Former mayoral candidate Betty Brown, also present at the meeting, said she had a meeting with Appraisal Systems personnel and that the company acknowledged and corrected a mistake on her assessment. She then appealed the tax revaluation and won further relief. There were others at the meeting who indicated similar success in meetings with Appraisal Systems.